Skip to main content
All CollectionsShipping
Handling Returns: The Complete Guide
Handling Returns: The Complete Guide
Ashleigh avatar
Written by Ashleigh
Updated over 2 months ago

Welcome to the comprehensive guide on everything related to returns!

Returns are part of running a business, and the right approach can make all the difference in preserving your profits and sanity. In this guide, we'll outline a return policy you can adopt, discuss how to minimize return risks, and provide insights into when a return or exchange makes financial sense. Let's get started.

Sample Return Policy

Here's a comprehensive return policy you can use. Unsure how to update your stores return policy? Click here

No Returns, Only Exchanges

We do not accept returns unless the item is damaged in transit. We do offer exchanges only if there's an issue with the product, such as incorrect sizing or a defect.

Damaged or Defective Items

If your product arrives damaged or defective, we will gladly replace it. Simply contact us with a photo of the damage or defect within 7 days of receiving the item, and we will get a replacement sent to you at no additional cost.

Return Shipping Costs

Return postage is the responsibility of the customer for all exchanges. If there is an exchange, the customer must pay for shipping. However, if the item is damaged or defective, we will cover the cost of shipping a replacement.

Conditions for Exchanges

To be eligible for an exchange, the item must be unused, in the same condition that you received it, and in its original packaging. Exchanges are accepted within 7 days of receipt of your order. Items that were delivered to an incorrect address due to customer error are not eligible. Exchanges will only be processed when the original item is received back to us.

Non-Returnable Items

Certain items are non-returnable, including perishable goods, intimate or sanitary products, and custom-made items. Please contact us if you have any questions about your eligibility for an exchange.

Incorrect Address Provided by Customer

It is the customer's responsibility to provide the correct shipping address. If an incorrect address is provided and the item is returned to us, the customer will be responsible for any additional shipping costs to resend the item.

Lost Packages

We are not responsible for packages lost in transit due to customer error in the shipping address. However, if a package is lost due to a carrier issue, we will work with the customer to resolve the situation and potentially offer a replacement or store credit.

Replacement Limitations

Replacements are limited to one time per order. If the replacement item is also reported as damaged or defective, we will assess the situation and determine the best course of action, which may include a refund or store credit.

Photos of Damaged Items

Customers must provide multiple photos of damaged or defective items from different angles, including the original packaging. This helps us process claims with the carrier and ensure a smooth resolution.

Restocking Fee

In certain situations, we may charge a restocking fee to cover administrative and handling costs.

Out of Stock Items for Exchanges

If an exchange is requested but the item is out of stock, we will offer either store credit or the option to choose a different item of equal value.

Fraud Prevention

We reserve the right to refuse exchanges if we suspect any fraud or abuse of our exchange policy.


Important Considerations for Managing Returns

Managing returns in a business can be challenging, especially when trying to protect your profit margins. Here are some things to keep in mind:

Is a Return Worth It?

Depending on the cost of the item, accepting a return might not always be the best approach. In many cases, it might make more sense to simply send an exchange or replace the item altogether.

Example: If an item costs you $5 to get to a customer's door, and they paid you $20 for it, you could replace that item up to four times before losing money. It’s worth considering that simply shipping a replacement might lead to happier customers and fewer logistical headaches, as opposed to managing the complexities of a return. It's normal for a small percentage of items to need a little extra love or customer service. Don't be alarmed if 1 out of 20, 30, or 40 orders comes with a little customer support.

Mitigate Financial Loss

Your goal should always be to minimize any financial loss while still keeping customers satisfied. This means aiming for exchanges or replacements rather than incurring the cost of return shipping, restocking, and additional processing. This is why the return policy is listed as such. As your business grows and you start to have consistently large financial outcomes week over week, you can experiment making your return policy even more flexible, but in our experience, this rarely leads to any positive financial impact. There is a big difference between a "no return policy" and the policy above. Having that alone puts 99% of customers at ease.

Preserve Revenue and Profits

A key strategy in handling returns is to preserve your revenue. Encourage exchanges instead of returns and try to resolve issues quickly. The less time you spend processing returns, the more time you have for growth and profit.


FAQs About Returns

Can customers return items if they just don’t want them anymore?

No, our policy is that we only accept exchanges, not returns, unless the item arrives damaged or defective.

What happens if the item is damaged during shipping?

If an item is damaged in transit, we will replace it at no cost. Customers should contact us with a photo of the damaged product within 7 days of receiving it.

Who pays for return shipping?

The customer is responsible for any return shipping costs for exchanges. However, in the case of a damaged or defective item, we cover the cost of shipping a replacement.

Why don’t we accept returns?

Returns are costly and annoying, and by avoiding them, we can keep our prices lower for all customers. We do our best to resolve issues by offering exchanges or replacements when necessary.

When does it make sense to replace rather than accept a return?

If the cost of the item is low, say $5 or $10, replacing it directly is more efficient. For example, if a customer paid $30 for an item that costs you $7 to ship, replacing the item up to three times is still more cost-effective than managing returns.

How can I get a refund or replacement from an AliExpress supplier if the item is defective?

To get a refund or replacement from an AliExpress supplier, follow these steps:

- Contact the Supplier: Log in to your AliExpress account and navigate to "My Orders." Find the specific order, and click on "Contact Seller."

- Provide Evidence: Clearly describe the issue to the supplier, and provide photos showing the defect or damage. Suppliers usually require visual proof before offering refunds or replacements.

- Open a Dispute: If the supplier is uncooperative, open a dispute with AliExpress. Go to the order in question and click on "Open Dispute." Make sure to do this within the dispute timeframe (typically 15-30 days after delivery).

- Ask for a Free Replacement: Suppliers are often more willing to offer a replacement rather than a full refund. Be clear in your request for a replacement to increase the likelihood of a favorable resolution.

Where should customers ship the returns?

If we do accept a return for an exchange, customers should ship the return to the address provided by us. Initially, you can have customers ship returns to your house. However, as your business grows, it may be more convenient to use a PO Box or a local mail receiving service like PostScan.com. Many of our coaches started with their home address and later transitioned to a PO Box or mail service once volume increased.

How should I handle return addresses?

It's important to provide a clear and accurate return address to customers when they need to send items back for an exchange. You can include your return address on your website's return policy page, in the exchange instructions sent to the customer, or on the return shipping label. If you're using a PO Box or a mail forwarding service, make sure it's capable of receiving packages.

Are customers responsible for shipping labels and return shipping costs?

Yes, customers are responsible for obtaining and paying for shipping labels when returning items for an exchange. They can choose their preferred shipping method, but we recommend using a trackable service to ensure the item reaches us safely.

What if a customer is being pushy about return shipping labels and I need to create a return label?

If a customer insists on you providing a return shipping label, you can accommodate them by creating a return label on their behalf. Shopify provides a feature to create return labels for customers. You can follow the instructions provided by Shopify here: Creating Return Labels. This can help improve customer satisfaction, especially in cases where the customer is particularly insistent.


Additional Considerations

Where to Put Your Return Address

Your return address should be clearly communicated to customers who need to send items back for an exchange. Here are some best practices:

- On Your Website: Include your return address on your "Returns & Exchanges" policy page.

- In Communication: Provide the return address in any email correspondence regarding the exchange.

-On Shipping Labels If you're providing a return shipping label, make sure your return address is correctly listed.

- Privacy Considerations: If you're using your home address, consider using a PO Box or a mail receiving service to maintain privacy as your business grows.

Customer Responsibility for Shipping Labels

Customers are generally responsible for obtaining and paying for shipping labels when returning items for an exchange. You should:

- Inform Customers: Clearly state in your return policy that customers are responsible for return shipping costs.

- Provide Guidance: Offer recommendations on shipping methods, such as using trackable services.

- Exceptions: In cases where the item is damaged or defective, you should cover the cost of shipping a replacement to the customer.

Handling Pushy Customers Regarding Return Labels

Sometimes, a customer may insist on you providing a return shipping label. To maintain good customer relations:

- Assess the Situation: Consider the cost of providing a return label versus the potential for customer dissatisfaction.

- Provide a Return Label: If you decide to provide a return label, you can create one using Shopify's return label feature. Follow Shopify's instructions here: Creating Return Labels.


Communicating with Customers: Template Scenarios and Corresponding Responses

Effective communication is essential when handling returns and exchanges. Below are templates for various common situations you may encounter:

Customer Requests an Exchange Due to Wrong Size

Subject: Exchange Request for Order #[Order Number]

---

Dear [Customer Name],

Thank you for reaching out to us regarding your recent purchase. We're sorry to hear that the item didn't fit as expected.

We would be happy to assist you with an exchange for the correct size. Please ensure the item is unused, in its original packaging, and send it to the following address:

[Your Return Address]

Please note that customers are responsible for return shipping costs for exchanges. Once we receive the item, we'll process your exchange promptly and send you the new size.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please don't hesitate to ask.

Warm regards,

[Your Name]

Customer Support Team

[Your Company Name]


Customer Reports a Damaged or Defective Item

Subject: Replacement for Damaged Item in Order #[Order Number]

---

Dear [Customer Name],

We sincerely apologize that your item arrived damaged. Customer satisfaction is our top priority, and we want to resolve this issue for you as quickly as possible.

Could you please provide us with a few photos of the damaged item and the packaging it came in? This will help us assess the situation and prevent similar issues in the future.

Once we receive the photos, we'll arrange for a replacement to be sent to you at no additional cost.

Thank you for your patience and understanding.

Best regards,

[Your Name]

Customer Support Team

[Your Company Name]


Customer Requests a Return for a Refund

Subject: Inquiry About Return for Order #[Order Number]

---

Dear [Customer Name],

Thank you for contacting us. We understand that sometimes a product may not meet expectations.

As outlined in our return policy, we currently offer exchanges but do not accept returns for refunds unless the item is damaged or defective upon arrival.

We would be happy to assist you with an exchange for another product that better suits your needs. Please let us know how you'd like to proceed, and we'll be glad to help.

We appreciate your understanding and look forward to finding a suitable solution.

Kind regards,

[Your Name]

Customer Support Team

[Your Company Name]


Customer Provided an Incorrect Shipping Address

Subject: Address Confirmation for Order #[Order Number]

---

Dear [Customer Name],

We noticed that the shipping address provided may be incomplete or incorrect. To ensure your order reaches you without delay, could you please confirm your full shipping address?

Please note that if an incorrect address is provided and the package is returned to us, additional shipping costs may apply to resend the item.

We're eager to get your order to you as soon as possible. Your prompt response is appreciated.

Thank you,

[Your Name]

Customer Support Team

[Your Company Name]


Customer Inquires About Lost Package

Subject: Update on Order #[Order Number] Delivery Status

---

Dear [Customer Name],

We're sorry to hear that you haven't received your order yet. Let me assist you in resolving this issue.

I've checked the tracking information, and it appears there may be a delay with the carrier. Sometimes, packages can be delayed due to unforeseen circumstances.

However, if the package is confirmed lost by the carrier, we will gladly arrange a replacement or offer store credit, whichever you prefer.

We appreciate your patience and will keep you updated on any developments.

Please let us know if you have any questions.

Sincerely,

[Your Name]

Customer Support Team

[Your Company Name]


Customer Wants to Return a Non-Returnable Item

Subject: Regarding Return Request for Order #[Order Number]

---

Dear [Customer Name],

Thank you for reaching out to us. We understand you wish to return [Product Name].

As mentioned in our return policy, certain items, such as perishable goods, intimate products, and custom-made items, are non-returnable for health and safety reasons.

We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause. If there's anything else we can assist you with or if you have questions about other products, please let us know.

We're here to help in any way we can.

Best wishes,

[Your Name]

Customer Support Team

[Your Company Name]


Customer Requests an Exchange but Item Is Out of Stock

Subject: Exchange Request for Order #[Order Number]

---

Dear [Customer Name],

We appreciate you contacting us about an exchange for your recent purchase.

Unfortunately, the item you requested is currently out of stock. We apologize for any disappointment this may cause.

We can offer you two options:

1. Choose an Alternative Item: You may select a different item of equal value from our store.

2. Receive Store Credit: We can issue store credit for the amount of your original purchase, which you can use at any time.

Please let us know which option you'd prefer, and we'll process it promptly.

Thank you for your understanding.

Warm regards,

[Your Name]

Customer Support Team

[Your Company Name]


Denying a Return Due to Policy Violation (e.g., Outside Return Window)

Subject: Regarding Your Return Request for Order #[Order Number]

---

Dear [Customer Name],

Thank you for reaching out to us.

We understand you wish to [return/exchange] your item. Our return policy accepts certian exchanges within 7 days of receiving your order. According to our records, your request was made [number of days] after the delivery date.

Unfortunately, we cannot process an exchange outside of this timeframe. We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause.

Please feel free to contact us if you have any questions or if there's any other way we can assist you.

Thank you for your understanding.

Sincerely,

[Your Name]

Customer Support Team

[Your Company Name]


Handling Suspected Fraudulent Return Requests

Subject: Inquiry About Return Request for Order #[Order Number]

---

Dear [Customer Name],

Thank you for your message.

We take customer satisfaction seriously and strive to resolve all issues promptly. However, we need additional information to process your request.

Could you please provide:

- Proof of purchase (order confirmation, receipt)

- Photos of the item from different angles, including packaging

- A brief description of the issue you're experiencing

This information will help us verify the details and find the best solution for you.

Thank you for your cooperation.

Best regards,

[Your Name]

Customer Support Team

[Your Company Name]

---

Note: If fraud is confirmed, respond according to your company's policies


Key Takeaways for Returns

- Think Financially: Always calculate the cost of a return versus the cost of a replacement. Most of the time, replacement is more profitable.

- Reduce Risk: Put as much responsibility as possible on the customer, such as covering return shipping.

- Prioritize Exchanges: Exchanges help you keep customers happy while preserving your revenue and avoiding complex logistics.

Handling returns efficiently is all about managing risk and preserving profits. By setting clear policies and understanding when a return makes sense, you can keep your business profitable while still keeping your customers satisfied.


Final Thoughts

Returns are an inevitable part of e-commerce, but with the right strategies and policies in place, they don't have to be a liability. By clearly communicating your return and exchange policies, setting appropriate expectations, and handling customer interactions professionally, you can turn potential challenges into opportunities to build trust and loyalty with your customers.

Remember, the key to a successful returns strategy in is adaptability, clear communication, and a focus on both profitability and exceptional customer service. As your business grows, continue to evaluate and adjust your return policies to best meet the needs of your customers while maintaining your bottom line.

Pro Tip: How to make money from customer interactions.

Turn any situation into a revenue generating opportunity by offering customer something like a $5 gift card, $10 gift card or 50% off their next order (offer expires in 24 hours) as a good-will gesture. When they use this gift not only does it make them feel good, but you'll actually profit more from that same customer. Win-win!

Did this answer your question?